I was reading, and oh boy, empathising, with Stressy Mummy today and her Big Ban Theory. This post rang true in so many ways and sparked me to put fingers to keyboard because we’ve been in the same boat and I’ve been meaning to blog about it for a couple of weeks.
It’s the great screen time debate – the one that I suspect becomes more apparent as the nights draw in, the weekends become wetter, the snot bringing bugs take over the schools and the onslaught of adverts becomes even greater.
The Sealion Keeper would happily watch TV all day, possibly with a spattering of laptop in the mix too. Neither of them have DS’s, Leapsters or any handheld tech, they are allowed to use the desktop, my laptop (with permission – usually for homework) and watch the TV. We only have Freeview, we don’t have any other channels. It’s just not been our thing and our physios demand advise us to keep as active as possible. It’s always been a hard one to call – any child is tired after school and needs/wants to crash out – the team from GOSH want me to be doing extra ‘fiddly fingers’ activities with them or getting them doing more physical activities. It generally results in a boom and bust cycle – work like mad things, end up ill, get better, repeat. We’re still working on getting that balance right.
The Cheetah Keeper loves his tech. He would happily play online for hours – mainly the games on CBBC and CBeebies but he also loves Teach Your Monster to Read and the maths sites that his sister has discovered at school. Oh, and the Zoo websites – but you’d probably guessed that already. I was also acutely aware that having limited his sister’s time on the computer when she was in Year 1, only to be pulled up at parents evening about her lack of ICT skills that I didn’t want to be in that position again.
His behaviour this autumn has been hard work. It’s been easier to let him have some time on the computer so that we can get ‘stuff’ done. Whilst his sister is happy to leap around her bedroom to whatever is on the radio or read her Olympic factfiles for the zillionth time, he (like his father) wants to achieve something – and getting to the next level on a game was providing that hit.
To make things ‘fair’ we were letting his sister have a little more TV time and factoring in our Friday “tea in front of the telly” treats – except they were becoming more than just on Fridays because I couldn’t deal with the fallout. It wasn’t good. We’d tried limiting time, rewarding good behaviour, stickers – our normal stash in our box of parenting tricks. They didn’t really work. The Cheetah Keeper was waking up way too early, the tiredness was affecting school, home and his temperament – and yet screen time seemed to calm him down – or at least give us some respite.
I had already started changing his diet – an increase in carbs towards the end of the day and the introduction, a couple of nights a week of fortified chocolate milk to try and up his iron levels. It was beginning to work but not well enough.
So we too, implemented the outright ban with a proper home-cooked dinner at 5pm. Spellings and other school jobs are done before school, not at bedtime and we read together whilst his sister is at her touch typing lesson before school. I’m exhausted but it’s working so well.
I have a different boy – the cuddly, funny, biddable, lego playing, colouring in (a new found delight), car racing, engineering, doodling and cooking one I used to have. It’s brilliant. He’s sleeping better, eating better, behaving phenomenally better and is doing better at school. His sister is finding it harder but we have some serious Christmas crafting planned and she’s suggested that we do her homework after school tomorrow before Brownies. Before she’d have been planning her viewing to the last minute to coordinate her uniform change between programmes.
They’re allowed to watch an hour or two of TV on Saturday and Sunday mornings – it’s now a treat (rather than an expected right) and it means we can get a little lie-in. We all snuggled up on the sofa to watch the last Grand Prix of the season last Sunday and it was fab – mainly because the Cheetah Keeper’s commentary beats anything the BBC can do.
They’ve asked to watch Octonauts a couple of evenings and I’m not adverse to 5 minutes of Newsround or the odd Blue Peter here and there. The Sealion Keeper can use the computer for her homework (how else am I expected to find out how tall Guy Fawkes was, the length of the M1 or Chris Hoy’s birthday?) and the Cheetah Keeper is allowed to play on the phonics site occasionally but they’re not asking to now. 2 weeks in and it seems to be working.
Instead we’ve made soup for Mammasaurus, got the hama beads out, improved the spelling test results significantly, increased the piano practice, rediscovered the joys of colouring and doodling books, finished another 2 Brownie badges and, in a moment of complete insanity, even got the Moon Sand out (section me now) – that’s just the tip of the stuff we’ve done.
They’re eating better, going to bed earlier, sleeping later and doing better at school. It’s not easy but I wish we’d done it earlier.
How does screen time work in your house? Would you reintroduce it if you were in my position?




28/11/2012 at 10:17 pm
This is a very timely thing. I have just banned it for my boys too. It’s that after school time now that they’re no longer running around the garden and I want peace to cook.. Like you say, the fall out is not worth it. It’s all too easy to get engrossed on line when they’re in front of the telly too.
28/11/2012 at 10:31 pm
hence my lack of twitter presence… x
29/11/2012 at 9:26 am
I’m lucky in that Scamp and Ozzy don’t asked to watch much tv, they ask to watch films often – and do but I think it’s all about balance and finding what works for you. And it sounds like you have done that!
I have never played with Moon sand – am I missing out ?!
29/11/2012 at 8:30 pm
We’ve never been a good film watching house – it’s never suited us and despite my best efforts, the children will not take to the idea. For us it doesn’t really meet the physio requirements so maybe it’s a good thing *sighs*. Moon Sand… hmmm… the perfect gift for the children of parents you don’t like very much. You can play with it next time you come here – outside.
29/11/2012 at 9:36 am
Wow, well done you. This is a really inspiring post. It’s so hard to get the balance right. My son has just started school this year and we’re still struggling to find our feet and get a routine that works for us and doesn’t leave all of us totally exhausted!
29/11/2012 at 8:28 pm
I agree, it’s so hard to get the balance right – and if you’d been in our house this afternoon you’d have said that I wasn’t doing particularly well. Exhaustion I’m concluding, is part of the deal – but if you find out the solution, will you let me know?? x
29/11/2012 at 7:58 pm
I rang the health visitor because of concerns from childminder and preschool about 3yo’s development. She came round to do an assessment and asked how much tv he watched. Without realising it, we’d gotten to the point where cbeebies was on most of the day. Turned off tv there and then, told him it was broken. Like you describe, I also got my lovely little boy back. Preschool noticed immediate change.
After about a 6 week ban, we decided to reintroduce tv in a limited way, 30 minutes a day, as a reward for pooing in the potty and not his pants. Behaviour immediately worse, and after 4 days we’re saying it’s broken again.
29/11/2012 at 8:26 pm
Our upstairs tv (in our bedroom, not theirs) is ‘broken’ at the moment. I miss us all piling into bed to watching tv with them on a Saturday morning but the long term benefits outweigh that (I just have to get my cuddle fix elsewhere). Hope the ‘broken’ tv produces the results again xx
30/11/2012 at 9:26 pm
That is a great post and it’s nice to see that you are further along the road than me and it is working. It has only been five days and there have been some improvements but L is having a tough time in school at the moment and that is reflected in his poor behaviour at home and the boys are seriously winding each other up. I am certainly going to rethink the amount of screen time as I agree that it definitely improves their behaviour and more importantly teaches them again that there is more to life!
30/11/2012 at 9:46 pm
We tried a little bit of tv this morning before school as the CK was up so early having got cold overnight. If I ever needed reassurance to stick with it, that was it. What a battle! He’s finding school hard going too, and is having physio once a week before school too but since reducing the screen time he’s found more of his own groove and and rather than trying to play ‘games’ in the playground he doesn’t understand (because he hasn’t seen the programme) he’s off doing the organised sport instead – and loving it. Today he asked to come home and do colouring – his sister flounced until she got into it… x